“I do not believe the spitting on the ball by the pitcher has any more effect upon the health of the player than spitting on the bait ‘for luck’ when fishing has to do with the size of the catch.”

In response to a school principal who said the use of the spitball was “a disgusting and pernicious example to thousands of boys,” Dr. Young did concede, “Unquestionably, there is much to be said in your behalf [sic] when the question is viewed from the standpoint of esthetics.”

“It’s quite possible some pitchers could add three, four or even five years to their careers if allowed to use the spitball…. Most spitballers had unusually long careers. A spitball is not a dangerous pitch and not harmful to the arm.”

“The Rules keep a pitcher from doing anything—even sneezing…. Sure, fans like to see free-hitting games, but I believe they want to see those hits earned fairly. We all know the game has softened a bit. I say, ’Let’s harden it up again! Let’s legalize something illegal! Let’s bring back the spitball!’”

“I believe bringing back the spitball would be a good thing for the game. I would like to see the pitchers get this additional weapon. The home-run increase could stand reduction, and the spitter would help considerably in that direction. Then too legalization of the spitter would be a new thing, a source of discussion everywhere.”

“The development of the spit-ball has improved present-day base ball [sic] more than any other thing. The spit-ball has made the game faster and more scientific than it was 10, 15, or 20 years ago, and many of the players who were classed as stars in the ‘olden days’ would be considered of but ordinary ability now.”

Unfortunately, Jennings does not elaborate. And a few year later he was reported to be anti-spitball.

“The Volstead Act was no harder on moisture, all in all, than the spitball rule. And the Volstead Act is dead. The dry law in baseball may last forever.”

“My impression is that the pitch [the spitter] was barred because it was being used as a cover-up for other kinds of pitches in which the ball was scuffed or doctored.

“If the spitter comes back, b’Judas Priest, ‘twill turn the game of baseball upside down.”

“They should legalize it [the spitball] and stop this nonsense. I’ve said this before, of course, but the mound is the only place where they get technical. Batters can cheat, fielders can cheat, and so can base runners. But they really bear down on the pitchers. Every major rule change while I’ve been in the big leagues has been against the pitcher.

“I’d like to see them give the pitcher the advantage of the spitter. It would help a lot of them. And it would stop those .230 hitters from complaining—those mediocres who are always looking for the alibi. If they couldn’t cry ‘spitter’ to the umpires, what would they moan about?

“The great ones never alibi. They blame themselves or they give credit to the pitcher, credit for making a good pitch. It is a story as old as the game of baseball.”

“The spitball is such a wonderful thing that I would like nothing better than to face an all-star team of the best batters in both leagues and show what I could do against them with my spitter—you know, some time when I am feeling just right. After you learn it, a spitter is an assassinator [sic] of batting averages….

“The spitball is less trying to the arm than an ordinary curve ball. It is not such a strain on the muscles. It does not involve such a twist as you deliver the ball.”